Vredestein Wintrac Pro

The Vredestein Wintrac Pro answers the growing market demands in the 17-inch and ultra-high-performance segment. The new winter tyre makes no concessions in terms of performance, offering maximum grip while cornering, short stopping distances on wet roads and great handling, even at high speeds. The Wintrac Pro is available in speed rating Y, making it appropriate for use at speeds of up to 300 km/h (186mph) for a large number of sizes. The tyre merges an attractive design with advanced technology.

This tyre replaced the Vredestein Wintrac xtreme S.

Dry Grip 91%
Wet Grip 90%
Road Feedback 85%
Handling 82%
Wear 87%
Comfort 87%
Buy again 93%
Snow Grip 90%
Ice Grip 83%

Tyre review data from 26 tyre reviews averaging 88% over 139,700 miles driven.

The Wintrac Pro is ranked 7th of 42 Winter Ultra High Performance tyres.

In Depth Tyre Comparisons

Latest Tyre Test Results

2023/24 Tyre Reviews UHP Winter Tyre Test - 3rd of 6 tyres

  • Positive - Very good in the wet, exceptional value with best wear and lowest cost per 1000 km by a considerable margin.
  • Negative - Worst snow performance of the test but no more than 5% behind the best. High rolling resistance.
  • Overall -
    .
View Full Test >>

2023 Tyre Reviews Winter Tyre Test - 8th of 13 tyres

  • Positive - Good in snow handling, good rolling resistance.
  • Negative - Extended dry braking, reduced grip in the wet with below average wet handling and lower than average aquaplaning resistance.
  • Overall - The Vredestein Wintrac Pro had a good snow performance overall, a low rolling resistance but did struggle more in the dry than the previous two tyres. The Wintrac Pro has been on the market for a long time, but it's still holding its own considering the talent of this group.
View Full Test >>

2023 ADAC 17 inch Winter Tyre Test - 5th of 15 tyres

  • Positive - Still good properties on winter roads, good predicted mileage, low abrasion, low fuel consumption.
  • Negative - Weaknesses in driving comfort on dry roads and in behavior at the limit, slight weaknesses on wet roads.
  • Overall - The VREDESTEIN WINTRAC PRO tyre exhibits satisfactory steering feedback and precision on dry roads, requiring occasional corrections during turns and corners. It tends to oversteer during dynamic maneuvers, and its braking distance is average but rated as good. In wet conditions, it excels in braking but scores only satisfactory in aquaplaning and handling. While it offers sufficient safety reserves, it lacks the precision for a higher rating. On winter roads, it receives good ratings for braking on snow and ice, as well as for snow traction and handling, although it could improve in precision. Environmentally, the tyre performs well with good predicted mileage and wear. Despite its slightly above-average weight, its low fuel consumption earns it a good efficiency rating.
View Full Test >>

2023 Tyre Tests

  • 3rd: 2023/24 Tyre Reviews UHP Winter Tyre Test (255/40 R19)
  • 5th: 2023 ADAC 17 inch Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R17)
  • 5th: 2023 Auto Bild SUV Winter Tyre Test (225/60 R18)
  • 5th: 2023 Sport Auto Winter Tyre Test (225/40 R18)
  • 6th: 2023 AMS SUV Winter Tyre Test (255/45 R20)
  • 7th: 2023 Sports Cars Winter Tyre Test (225/40 R18)
  • 8th: 2023 Tyre Reviews Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R18)
  • 8th: 2023 Auto Bild Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R18)
  • 17th: 2023 Winter Tyre Test 54 Set Braking Test (225/45 R18)
  • 2022 Tyre Tests

  • 3rd: 2022 AMS Winter Tyre Test (245/45 R19)
  • 3rd: 2022 Auto Bild SUV Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R19)
  • 5th: 2022 Auto Zeitung Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R17)
  • 6th: 2022/23 Tyre Reviews Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R17)
  • 6th: 2022 Sports Car UHP Winter Tyre Test (245/40 R19)
  • 12th: 2022 Auto Bild Winter Tyre Test (215/55 R17)
  • 20th: 2022 Winter Tyre Market Overview (215/55 R17)
  • 2021 Tyre Tests

  • 3rd: 2021 Auto Bild Sports Car Winter Tyre Test (245/40 R18)
  • 4th: 2021 Auto Bild SUV Winter Tyre Test (235/55 R18)
  • 4th: 2021 AZ SUV Winter Tyre Test (235/55 R18)
  • 5th: 2021 ADAC 17 Inch Winter Tyre Test (225/50 R17)
  • 2020 Tyre Tests

  • 3rd: 2020 Auto Bild SUV Winter Tyre Test (225/55 R17)
  • 4th: The Best Winter Tyres for 2020 (205/55 R16)
  • 5th: 2020 ADAC Winter Tyre Test - 235/55 R17 (235/55 R17)
  • 6th: 2020 Winter Tyre Market Overview - 52 Tyre Braking Test (245/45 R18)
  • 8th: 2020 ACE Winter Tyre Test (225/50 R17)
  • 12th: 2020 Auto Bild Performance Winter Tyre Test (245/45 R18)
  • 2019 Tyre Tests

  • 2nd: 2019 19 Inch Performance Winter Tyre Test (255/35 R19)
  • 3rd: 2019 AMS Winter SUV Tyre Test (215/55 R17)
  • 5th: 2019 Auto Express Winter Tyre Test (225/45 R17)
  • 6th: 2019 Winter Tyre Test Market Overview (225/45 R17)
  • 6th: 2019 Auto Bild Winter 17 inch Tyre Test (225/45 R17)
  • 2018 Tyre Tests

  • 1st: 2018 Autobild UHP Winter Tyre Test (245/45 R18)
  • Size Fuel Wet Noise Weight
    215/40 R17 87V XL   E B 72 8.80kgs
    225/45 R17 94H XL   E B 72 9.59kgs
    215/50 R17 95V XL   C B 72 9.32kgs
    225/50 R17 98H XL   E B 72 10.29kgs
    205/55 R17 91H   C C 72 9.55kgs
    235/55 R17 103V XL   C B 72 12.06kgs
    235/55 R17 99H   C B 72 12.06kgs
    215/60 R17 96H   C B 72 10.30kgs
    205/40 R18 86V XL   F B 72 11.32kgs
    225/40 R18 92W XL   E B 72 10.57kgs
    245/45 R18 100V XL   C B 72 11.16kgs
    225/55 R18 102V XL   C B 72 10.94kgs
    255/55 R18 109V XL   C B 73 13.93kgs
    225/60 R18 104V XL   C B 72 12.64kgs
    235/65 R18 110H XL   C B 72 13.31kgs
    245/35 R19 93Y XL   F B 72 11.23kgs
    275/35 R19 100W XL   E B 73 12.96kgs
    225/40 R19 93Y XL   E B 72 9.97kgs
    245/40 R19 98W XL   E B 72 11.20kgs
    255/45 R19 104V XL   E B 72 13.06kgs
    235/50 R19 103V XL   C B 72 12.81kgs
    275/30 R20 97Y XL   F B 73 12.65kgs
    245/35 R20 95Y XL   E B 72 11.75kgs
    275/35 R20 102Y XL   E B 73 13.51kgs
    245/40 R20 99Y XL   E B 72 12.78kgs
    255/40 R20 101Y XL   E B 73 13.23kgs
    295/40 R20 110V XL   C B 73 15.45kgs
    235/45 R20 100V XL   E B 72 12.55kgs
    255/55 R20 110V XL   C B 72 15.21kgs
    255/40 R21 102V XL   E B 72 13.61kgs
    315/40 R21 115V XL         16.00kgs
    245/45 R21 104W XL   E B 72 13.41kgs

    Sorry, we don't currently have any questions and answers for the Vredestein Wintrac Pro. Why not submit a question to our tyre experts using the form below!

    Ask a question

    We will never publish or share your email address

    capatha

    To verify you're human please type the word you see above in the box below.


    Size Price Range  
    Available in 4 tyre sizes - View all.

    YouTube Review

    Top 3 Vredestein Wintrac Pro Reviews

    Given 94% while driving a Audi S5 (255/40 R19 V) on a combination of roads for 5,000 spirited miles
    Great winter tyres, highly recommend. Amazing traction in the Scottish winter and snow. Good handling balance at the limit and provides plenty of feedback of the road surface. Corners and grips well in temperatures under 0 degrees Celsius. A must buy for any performance vehicle if looking to drive spiritedly in the colder months. Driving a stage 2 Audi S5 with 485 Bhp, a good tyre is a must even with Quattro to put the power down when the road is slippery, wet and cold. The tyre is vary predictable at the limit when driving on an dry road and provides confidence when braking. Would buy again.
    Helpful 80 - tyre reviewed on March 12, 2021
    Given 85% while driving a BMW M240i (225/40 R18 W) on a combination of roads for 200 average miles
    I've had several types / makes of winter tyres fitted to different cars over the years (Mini Cooper S, BMW X5's), although this is an initial review and we haven't had any severe weather yet these tyres seem excellent and better that I have had in the past (plus this car is more powerful (340bhp) and rear wheel drive...). We've only driven the car in temperatures at zero degC and above but we've had some horrendous weather with heavy rain and high winds, driving with these tyres really in both small country roads and main dual carriageways with aquaplane conditions these have been sure footed, I have to commend them. I hope that come snow and the real harsh weather that will come shortly they will continue to impress.
    Helpful 125 - tyre reviewed on November 30, 2018
    Given 78% while driving a Jaguar Jaguar XE (255/35 R19) on mostly country roads for 5,000 spirited miles
    Purchased in sizes 225/40 r19y front and 255/35 r19y rear for Jaguar xe awd. Excellent on dry and wet, very good on fresh snow, on ice I don't know. They are silent and with a soft compound. They may not excel in one category, but they are very homogeneous and suitable for all weather conditions. Very stable at high speeds. Honestly I would buy them again.
    Helpful 30 - tyre reviewed on December 4, 2022
    Have you driven on the Vredestein Wintrac Pro tyre?

    Have YOU got experience with the Vredestein Wintrac Pro? Help millions of other tyre buyers

    Review your Vredestein Wintrac Pro >

    Latest Vredestein Wintrac Pro Reviews

    Given 80% while driving a Suzuki SX4 Scross 1.4T Boosterjet (215/55 R17) on mostly town for 5,000 spirited miles
    Very nice tires from Vredestein! Got them as partially worn with 7.0mm front and 7.7mm back. Installed them a little late (end of November in The Netherlands, average temp. was 5°C), and there was a noticeable difference compared to the factory Conti's. First, the rolling resistance is very high on these, went from 23km per litre to no higher than 18km per litre. The grip in the cold wet is very nice, never had a doubt. Dry is OK for a Winter tire, they like to squeal in hard dry corners between 7° and 15°c. Took them off end of April, and the wear is very good, about 0.9mm front worn off and 0.4 back, in about 4000 miles with occasionally testing the limits in the corners. Sound is noticeable, but not annoying. No snow or ice as we had a very mild winter. Recommended as a slightly cheaper option in expensive sizes.
    Helpful 13 - tyre reviewed on May 11, 2023
    Given 97% while driving a Audi A6 Allroad 3.0 TDI (225/55 R17) on a combination of roads for 3,100 average miles
    An amazingly comfortable tyre, great cushioning for a car weighing 2,000 kg and incredibly quiet. Road properties in winter are fully satisfactory, the car sticks to the road and does not lose traction.
    Helpful 20 - tyre reviewed on March 21, 2023
    What to know the BEST All Season Tyres for 2024? Click to find out!
    Given 94% while driving a BMW 520d M Sport (245/45 R18) on mostly motorways for 20,000 average miles
    Excellent value for money, especially for luxury sedans like the Bmw G30. Check the tire tests and after 5 years of its presentation it is at the very top... I am thinking of buying it again.
    Helpful 16 - tyre reviewed on January 13, 2023
    Given 89% while driving a Mercedes Benz GLE 350de (315/40 R21) on a combination of roads for 900 easy going miles
    Was originally going for Pilot Alpin 5 SUV, but there were some delays when ordering so got these instead in 275/45/21 and 315/40/21 on a 2850kg car. There has been ice, snow, slush, dry and wet weather since I put these on and I must say I am impressed over how these perform. For a heavy SUV these tyres feel very well, cant really compare it to anything else as this is the first winter with this car, but we have a EV SUV that weighs 2650kg with Nokian R3 and I feel the Vredesteins suit a heavier car better the Nokians. Braking and grip on snow felt pretty much the same, although I had an impression of more control with the Vredesteins when braking and trying to provoke sliding. They aren’t remarkable on ice, but rarely non studded tyres are. Consumption is a bit higher than the sportcontact 6 summer tires and road noise is pretty much the same. Will probably try the Pilot Alpin 5 due to lower rolling resistance next time.
    Helpful 16 - tyre reviewed on December 16, 2022
    Given 81% while driving a Toyota 86 GT (225/40 R18) on a combination of roads for 2,000 spirited miles
    The Vredestein Wintrac Pro replaced a set of Continental TS830P on my Toyota GT86. For a sporty car they offer a lot of steering feedback, both in the dry and the wet. They are closer in handling to a summer tire than any winter tire I've used so far. Aquaplaning hasn't been an issue for me so far. On snow they offer decent traction from a standstill without being impressive. Cornering on snow on the other hand is really confidence inspiring. I can't tell about the wear on these as I don't run them on my main commuter car - so tires usually get replaced bacause of age, not because of wear. In summary I would recommend these for sporty cars in mild winter conditions.
    Helpful 16 - tyre reviewed on October 3, 2022
    Given 76% while driving a Honda Civic Type R (235/40 R18) on a combination of roads for 22,000 easy going miles
    Life cycle end review of the Wintrac Pro. 4th season, about 35000km, maybe a bit more, various countries, road conditions and driving styles, mostly smooth, relaxed touring. High speed stability is great. Only tested it once, during the 3rd season. Speed rating W, so up to 270km/h(168mph), got it up to 262km/h without any problems. Handling is good, not great, but it's predictable and you feel, when it starts to wash out. Strange rubbing noise, when they do though. Rubber got noticably harder over the 4 years. Stones quickly break parts of the thread out or squishes them down permanently, leaving holes in the otherwise prestine rubber blocks. Smaller stones get stuck easily and cause for quite some noise, especially in corners. Dry grip is great, once the tyres are warm. When cold, grip levels are mediocre, fine for city driving. Sporty driving is not recommended until they have at least some warmth in them. Curvy b roads make for a good place to warm them up. Wet grip is similar to dry grip. Slightly difficult, when greasy. The tyres will grip after washing out a bit, making the turn in a bit jerky at slightly higher speeds or when still cold. Aquaplaning is hardly an issue, once the tyres have warmed up, at least at speeds, that are common on roads. 120km/h in pouring rain is doable. There are enough grip reserves, but any higher than that is not recommended, except for short amounts of time to overtake the truck, that sprays your wind screen. Snow grip is astonishingly good, only a few problems there. Up to 100km/h, the tyres are predictable in a straight line, and safe to change lanes, when there is slush and snow between lanes. Braking is good, especially at lower speeds. Rear wheels might break out in corners, easy to do lift of oversteer in a FWD car. Snow grip didn't get much worse over the 4 seasons, than it was in the beginning. Tyres prefer deep, fresh snow, rather than flattened one from other drivers. Ice grip is not good. Even thin layers of ice on the road can quickly lead to the front washing out, even in low speeds. Definitely not recommended. If the ice is rough, the rubber grips a bit better, but still makes for an unpleasent ride. Ice driving requires very gentle stearing input and thinking at least 100m ahead. Comfort and tyre noise is good, gets splightly worse over time, but not unbearibly so. Mostly due to the rubber becoming harder and the thread blocks developing holes from stones, that squished and deformed them permanently. Thread wear is absolutely fantastic. 35000km and still 6mm of thread left on all 4 tyres. Mostly gentle, economic driving, very few hard accelerations or braking. Greasy, none road surfaces are astonishingly hardly a problem. Went on a ferry to Sweden, where other tyres struggled for grip, the Wintrac Pro made it up the damp ramps easily. Sweden's rough road surface didn't inpact the thread wear at all, as it seems. Measured the thread depth before and after the 2500km trip, no difference measurable. Noise levels rose a bit, naturally. Steering was not impacted though. 22° decline on wet cobble stone was also no problem. Very little slip, if any. For middle European winter conditions, I'd give them an 8/10. Best for climates with little ice and either lots of fresh snow or hardly any snow. Winter climates with lots of rain are absolutely no problem whatsoever. Sporty driving is also no problem, but you have to be aware of understeer and sudden gains of grip. Excelent for long road trips.
    Helpful 29 - tyre reviewed on January 23, 2022
    Given 90% while driving a BMW M140i (225/40 R18) on a combination of roads for 2,000 miles
    Great winter tyres, needed a short period of bedding in but great in snow/ice plus good wet and dry performance, in a tyre that you can still drive relatively hard with if you want. This is my winter tyre so I accept that it's going to compromise performance for snow/ice grip so you have to decide whether you want to swap every year between summers and winters, if not I wouldn't run these all year round, they would wear out too quickly as they're seriously sticky for snow and ice. If you do need winters, look no further, for the price (they were almost the cheapest quality winter tyres @ £91 each) they're quite a bit less than the competition and performed so well on snow/ice I can't recommend enough. Bedding in period is around 50 miles or so where the wet grip was quite bad, I was starting to regret buying them, but after this they're great that's quite important to remember. Also they are quite a soft tyre with a soft sidewall so I've found I can't use all the power (340bhp in my m140i because the rear of the car sqirms around and is quite unnerving. It will roll left to right until you back off. Its not the speed that is the problem, they're V rated to 150 mph so no problem they're, it's just the power or torque flexing the sidewalls I guess. If you don't have a powerful car like the m140i you'd probably never notice it, I can still accelerate quite fast, just not full throttle. At a guess I'd say up to about 260bhp you probably won't notice it and certainly not a reason to avoid buying these tyres. If you're using winter tyres you have to expect some loss in total performance, and I paid nearly half what something like a Michelin Alpin is, and around £30 per tyre less than Bridgestone and Goodyear alternatives. I was genuinely shocked at how good they were in the snow/ice. The road was Kirkstone Pass, it snowed over night and we went over the pass to see the snow and test out the tyres. So many cars were getting stuck, turning around, and 1 even crashed and was waiting to get recovered. I watched for about 20 minutes while I decided if these snow tyres were actually good enough as I didn't want to crash my new (to me) m140i! Didnt need to worry at all, going down first I was doing lots of brake tests to make sure I wasn't just sliding on ice and it stopped very well, no slipping. Then coming back up the steep hill it didn't even slip, I then slowed right down and accelerated gently to see if I wasn't just on the edge of the grip or something, still no slip. I had to really give push the throttle to get any slip, I definitely couldn't have made it slip without going over the top on purpose with the throttle, so impressed. Using these from now on as Winter tyres on my m140i which has Michelin Super Sports fitted in the summer. One more thing specific to my car, it comes standard with 225 50 18 front and 245 35 18 rear (something like that), but for winter tyres it's perfectly safe to fit 225 40 18 92Y all round, it even says that tyre size on the sticker beside the drivers door, I was trying to figure this out for ages so for anyk e else wanted to know winter tyre sizes for an m140i on standard 18's it's 225 40 18 92Y all round. 88Y load rating isn't good enough so don't buy those (I also read that somewhere).
    Helpful 28 - tyre reviewed on January 14, 2022
    Given 88% while driving a Volkswagen Tiguan (225/45 R17) on mostly country roads for 1,000 average miles
    My Tiguan R uses Y rated 255/35 21 and there is a limited choice of tyres in this size. The Wintrac Pro did well in the 2021 Auto Bild winter tyre test so I decided to give them a go. Initial impressions are very good, especially in the wet where they happily keep 316 bhp in check. In the dry the steering feel, handling and braking is almost as good as a summer tyre. In the cold and wet they are better than a summer and on the country roads I commute to work on they have really inspired confidence in the recent cold, wet weather. There is a little more tyre noise than an equivalent summer tyre but the ride quality is fine. I have yet to try them on ice or snow but the Auto Bild test seems to indicate I have nothing to worry about and it is too early to comment on wear rates.
    Helpful 18 - tyre reviewed on January 4, 2022
    Given 93% while driving a BMW M240i (225/45 R17) on a combination of roads for 3,000 spirited miles
    Winter time. Came from Michelin PS4 summer tyres. When changing to Vredestein Wintrac Pro straight away i've noticed it handles like the Michelin. Very stable, tight handling. Grip is amazing. Having a Stage2 M240i with 480bhp. Accelerating from 0 is spot on. Almost no wheelspin! And that for RWD!! In wet it feels very confident. No issues at all. First day of big snow, I went for a big trip with my buddy. Leaving the parking uphill, it went like on dry surface. My buddy took 30min to finally get free. Just proves how amazing the Vredestein is. And really shows a wintertyre is the best choice in these winter condition. Trust level 100. Wouldn't choose any other tyre than this. You wont regret it
    Helpful 25 - tyre reviewed on March 4, 2021
    Given 87% while driving a Ford fiesta st (205/55 R18) on mostly town for 6,000 average miles
    I bought these tyres in November 2019 and had them fitted to my 2019 Ford Fiesta ST. There was very little choice for winter tyres when it came to the wheel size on this car so I was limited to only this one or the very overpriced Pirelli Sotozero 3s. For the first winter that I had them fitted it was mostly just cold and wet (no snow) but the level of grip that this tyre offers over the Michelin pilot super sports (fitted to this car as standard) in temperatures below about 5°C is worth it even if you don’t get any snow. Fast forward to December 2020/January 2021 and I can confirm that in the snow these tyres are extremely capable. A full three inches of snow is no problem for these tyres. I have also used these tyres on icy roads and they hold up well there too, with abs breaking coming on when you slam the breaks but it stopping the car some several meters shorter than if you had summer tyres on. The tyres also preform equally as well in slushy/wet snow. If I had to rate the handling/breaking for fresh dry snow I would say 10/10, for slushy/wet snow 9/10 and icy roads would be 8/10. It’s also worth noting that even after 6000 miles on these tyres there is very little wear and they probably still have another full winter in them if not 2. Overall a fantastic tyre that significantly improves the safety of your car during the winter.
    Helpful 20 - tyre reviewed on January 24, 2021
    Given 88% while driving a Audi S3 (225/40 R18) on mostly country roads for 4,000 spirited miles
    Bought these last year for my then new-to-me Facelift Audi S3 to replace some General Tyres(!) summers that the dealers fitted before I bought the car. I was impressed with the Vredestein Wintrac Extremes I'd run a good few years ago on my Yeti, so thought I'd give these a go as they are UHP rated. They were a definite improvement over the Generals, but as I didn't know the car, it wasn't really a good comparison. During this summer however, I ran Michelin PS4s on the S3, & they didn't seem the big step up from the Wintrac Pros I was expecting, & now I've refitted the Vreds I noticed straight away that the steering's actually better, the car's slightly quieter & ride's better than it was on the PS4s. I found the Wintrac Pros really good in the wet & in cold, dry conditions but I didn't get the opportunity to drive on snow or much ice last year so can't comment on that yet, & I'm not really expecting great wear, but dynamically & subjectively these are a great winter tyre & good value. If we get proper winter weather this year, I'll update accordingly & it'll be interesting to compare them to the Dunlop Wintersport 5s that are currently on the Yeti (which subjectively & for grip in all conditions have been really impressive) but so far, highly recommend these Wintrac Pros.
    Helpful 26 - tyre reviewed on December 11, 2020
    Given 89% while driving a Honda Civic Type R (235/40 R18 W) on a combination of roads for 12,000 easy going miles
    The tyres need a short warm up phase to grip on slippery road around freezing. City driving is not really enough to get them to grip well enough, that you don't experience slip at acceleration from a stand still. Once moving, they quickly bite into the road surface when dry, wet and snowy roads are a little more tricky. The confidence you build on snow and slush is phenomenal though. As long as you drive smoothly, the tyres keep you on track even in tight corners. Bumps and pot holes are transfered to your bum quite directly, but not as harsh as with the 245/30 summer tyres. Aquaplaning sets in at closer to 100km/h with nearly new tyres. Thread wear is great. Over the 20000km in mild weather on motorway and city streets, they still look almost as new. Smooth driving and no hard exeleration or braking are key for long thread life. Cornering feels a little less direct than on the 245/30 summer tyres and I wouldn't recommend track use. Though rated up to 270km/h, sporty driving is possible. Long distance driving is okay. Road noise is acceptable, comfort is good. Comfort setting goes best with the Wintrac Pro for everyday driving, if your car has different driving modes. They do take emergency manouvers very well though. Though I have no experience, if they do well under repeated manouvers. The tyres quickly tell you, when they lose traction, gaining it back quickly as well.
    Helpful 16 - tyre reviewed on April 13, 2020