2020 ACE Mid Range Summer Tyre Test

Test Summary
Best tyre for dry roadsMaxxis Premitra HP5
Best tyre for wet roadsFulda SportControl 2
The best tyre overallMaxxis Premitra HP5
The lowest fuel useFirestone RoadHawk
The quietest tyreSava Intensa UHP 2
Fulda SportControl 2
Apollo Aspire XP
Kleber Dynaxer HP4
Avon ZV7
The best value tyreMaxxis Premitra HP5
Sava Intensa UHP 2
The talented guys at ACE Europe have just released their first summer tyre test for 2020, and interestingly they've tested nine 215/55 R17 summer tyres from the mid range sector of the market!

Sadly, like ADAC, ACE doesn't provide any of the raw data, but the test still provides a rather unique insight into how the highly contested midrange sector of the market looks. These tyres often save you money when compared to a premium tyre, but don't fall into the performance category of "ditch finders" like budget tyres can. It's a shame there's no premium tyre as a benchmark, but it's something we're looking to do in the future!

The Best of the Mid Range

If you've been following tyre tests from the past 12 months, it should be no surprise that the Maxxis Premitra HP5 wins the test, acing nearly all the categories and showing no real weakness.

Goodyear will be pleased with their second tier brands Sava and Fulda, as they essentially matched their overall performance, locking out second and third spots.

Apollo, the owners of Vredestein, take fourth place, with a slight weakness in the wet, and everyone's midrange favourite brand Toyo struggled a little more in the dry for fifth.

Kleber, owned by Michelin, could only manage sixth place overall, again struggling in the wet but proving to be very quiet, where the Bridgestone owned Firestone also struggled on the wet surfaces, but had very low fuel useage.

Rounding out the test are Hankook and Avon. Both brands will be disappointed, but in particular this is a very unusual result for Hankook who are now considered a premium brand, and often beat premium rivals.

Results

1st: Maxxis Premitra HP5

Maxxis Premitra HP5
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 308
  2. Dry: 51
  3. Wet: 60
  4. Rolling Resistance: 18
  5. Noise: 7
  6. Cost: 18
  7. Overall: 154
Short braking and good handling in the dry and wet, high aquaplaning resistance, low fuel use, good value
None mentioned
Highly Recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £72.40

2nd: Sava Intensa UHP 2

Sava Intensa UHP 2
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 292
  2. Dry: 47
  3. Wet: 56
  4. Rolling Resistance: 17
  5. Noise: 8
  6. Cost: 18
  7. Overall: 146
Good wet handling, high resistance to aquaplaning, low noise, good value
Long wet braking
Recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £69.50

3rd: Fulda SportControl 2

Fulda SportControl 2
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 290
  2. Dry: 47
  3. Wet: 61
  4. Rolling Resistance: 17
  5. Noise: 8
  6. Cost: 12
  7. Overall: 145
Short braking and good handling in the wet, good aquaplaning resistance
Relatively expensive
Recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £84.40

4th: Apollo Aspire XP

Apollo Aspire XP
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 272
  2. Dry: 45
  3. Wet: 51
  4. Rolling Resistance: 17
  5. Noise: 8
  6. Cost: 15
  7. Overall: 136
Low noise
Average wet and dry handling, low lateral aquaplaning resistance
Recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £76.61

5th: Toyo Proxes Sport

Toyo Proxes Sport
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 270
  2. Dry: 44
  3. Wet: 56
  4. Rolling Resistance: 16
  5. Noise: 7
  6. Cost: 12
  7. Overall: 135
Short wet braking distances, good aquaplaning resistance
Long dry braking, high rolling resistance, expensive
Recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £75.20

6th: Kleber Dynaxer HP4

Kleber Dynaxer HP4
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 258
  2. Dry: 47
  3. Wet: 45
  4. Rolling Resistance: 17
  5. Noise: 8
  6. Cost: 12
  7. Overall: 129
Low noise
Average wet handling, weak aquaplaning resistance, expensive
Conditionally recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £78.00

7th: Firestone RoadHawk

Firestone RoadHawk
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 252
  2. Dry: 44
  3. Wet: 43
  4. Rolling Resistance: 20
  5. Noise: 5
  6. Cost: 14
  7. Overall: 126
Very low rolling resistance
Long wet braking, poor wet handling, long dry braking, high noise
Conditionally recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £80.57

8th: Hankook Ventus Prime 3 K125

Hankook Ventus Prime 3 K125
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 244
  2. Dry: 47
  3. Wet: 36
  4. Rolling Resistance: 19
  5. Noise: 7
  6. Cost: 13
  7. Overall: 122
Good handling in the dry, low rolling resistance
Poor wet handling, very poor lateral aquaplaning resistance
Conditionally recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £76.24

9th: Avon ZV7

Avon ZV7
  • 215/55 R17
  1. Total: 238
  2. Dry: 41
  3. Wet: 41
  4. Rolling Resistance: 16
  5. Noise: 8
  6. Cost: 13
  7. Overall: 119
Low noise
Long braking distances and poor handling in the dry, high rolling resistance
Conditionally recommended

Read Reviews    Buy from £72.03

Similar Tyre Tests





Discussion:

comments powered by Disqus